Fiberglass Pools: Are They Good & Are There Better Options

Fiberglass Pools: Are They Good & Are There Better Options

Welcome to our deep dive into the world of swimming pools, specifically focusing on the myths of fiberglass pools. At Gib-San Pools, we have over five decades of experience in crafting custom, luxurious pools for our discerning clients. Today, we want to clear the air about some common misconceptions surrounding fiberglass pools and provide you with the insights you need to make an informed decision.


About Us

What is a Fiberglass Pool?

A fiberglass pool is a type of swimming pool made from fiberglass-reinforced plastic moulded into a basin shape. This manufacturing process involves forming layers of fiberglass into the desired shape and coating them with a gelcoat layer to create a smooth, durable surface. Fiberglass pools are typically known for their durability and ease of maintenance, making them a popular choice among homeowners, but, unfortunately, much of this is not accurate and can be affected by various factors.

Fiberglass Pools: Are They as Good as We Think?

Fiberglass pools are popular because manufacturers say they are cheaper and quicker to install. However, this isn’t always true, and they might not be the perfect fit for every homeowner, especially those looking for a highly customized solution. To learn why, we’ll discuss some of the myths around fiberglass pools and what other options homeowners have for constructing their perfect swimming pool.

Fiberglass Myths: True or False

Let’s debunk some common myths about fiberglass pools:

Myth: Fibereglass pools are more energy efficient.

False. While fiberglass pools are often praised for their insulation properties, real-world energy efficiency depends more on maintenance practices, the usage of automatic covers, and efficient plumbing systems.

Myth: Fiberglass pools require fewer chemicals for upkeep compared to other pool materials.

False. The chemical usage for pool maintenance depends on several factors, including exposure to sunlight and pool usage patterns, rather than the pool type alone. Fiberglass pools can grow algae like all others.

Myth: Fiberglass pools last longer and are more durable.

False. While fiberglass pools can last for years, they do not compare to the indefinite lifespan of concrete pools. Over time, environmental factors and chemical treatments can degrade fiberglass pools.

Myth: Fiberglass pools are eco-friendly.

False. Manufacturing and transporting fiberglass pools can contribute to air and water pollution, and their disposal can be problematic due to the challenges of recycling fiberglass.

Better Pool Material Options: Concrete & Vinyl

While many homeowners immediately think a fiberglass swimming pool is their go-to, there are other (and better) options! Materials like concrete and vinyl offer more customization, durability and longevity—not to mention they look great! Here are some of the benefits of concrete and vinyl pools.

Concrete Pools

Three lounge chairs, a seating area and a small pool house surround a modern concrete pool in a residential backyard.

Customization and Versatility: Concrete pools are celebrated for their vast design flexibility. They can be crafted into any shape, size, or depth and can incorporate a variety of features like vanishing edges, built-in seating, sun ledges or unique depths tailored to specific activities such as diving.

Longevity: Concrete is robust and durable, making it ideal for long-term use. A well-maintained concrete pool can last indefinitely, providing decades of enjoyment without the need for significant renovations. Think of the Trevi Fountain in Rome, the CN Tower, and the Toronto subway tunnels, all of which were constructed with concrete.

Resistance to Damage: Concrete’s robust nature allows it to better withstand natural shifts in the ground and severe weather conditions over time. 

Aesthetic Appeal: Concrete pools can be finished with a multitude of materials, including tiles, stones, or pebbles, offering an upscale look that can be completely customized to match the aesthetic of any luxury home.

Long-Term Value: Concrete pools significantly enhance the property value due to their permanence and aesthetic appeal. Potential home buyers often view concrete pools as a high-end feature that adds to the desirability and resale value of a home.

Vinyl Liner Pools

Cost-Effective Customization: Vinyl pools provide a balance between cost and customization. They are less expensive than concrete pools but offer more flexibility in design than fiberglass pools. Vinyl liners can be updated or changed, allowing homeowners to refresh their pool’s look without a complete overhaul.

Comfort and Design: The soft surface of the vinyl liner is gentle on feet and offers a comfortable swimming experience. Vinyl pools can also be designed in an array of patterns and colours, providing an aesthetic flexibility that can suit any homeowner’s taste.

Simple to Repair: Should a vinyl liner become damaged, it can be repaired or replaced relatively easily and at a lower cost than repairing a fiberglass or concrete pool. This makes maintaining the pristine look of the pool more manageable and cost-effective.

Adaptability to Seasonal Changes: Vinyl liner pools can better adapt to seasonal temperature fluctuations. The liner material is somewhat flexible, which helps it withstand the expansion and contraction that comes with changing temperatures, reducing the risk of damage.

Quick Installation: Vinyl pools are quicker to install than concrete pools, though they do require more frequent liner replacements over the pool’s lifespan.

For those looking to invest in a pool, considering factors like budget, usage, design preferences, and maintenance commitment is essential. Whether you’re looking for the robust versatility of a concrete pool or the cost-effective customization of a vinyl pool, be sure to check out this year’s latest trends in outdoor living and swimming pools. And don’t forget, Gib-San Pools is ready to help you choose the best option for your needs! 

Explore our extensive pool services here or get in touch with us directly to book a consultation and get a free quote.

Fiberglass Pools FAQs

Q1: Are fiberglass pools a good choice for Canadian climates?

Fiberglass pools can be suitable for milder climates but may not be the best choice in regions with severe temperature fluctuations, where materials like concrete prove more resilient.

Q2: Can fiberglass pools be customized to fit any backyard design?

Due to their pre-formed nature, fiberglass pools offer limited customization compared to other types, such as concrete or vinyl, which can be moulded to virtually any design and shape.

Q3: What are the long-term costs associated with owning a fiberglass pool?

While fiberglass pool manufacturers want buyers to think the initial cost might be lower, potential challenges in maintenance and repair can increase the total cost of ownership over time.

Design and Build Your Perfect Pool With the Experts at Gib-San

View of a large residential backyard at dusk, featuring a mid-sized concrete pool with two fire columns, lounge chairs and seating area.

Interested in a custom pool design that perfectly fits your luxury home and lifestyle? At Gib-San Pools, we specialize in designing and building bespoke concrete and vinyl pools that are built to last and crafted to your exact specifications. Explore our design and build services here, or contact us to discuss your dream pool project with our experts.

Reach out today and start your journey toward your ideal backyard retreat!

Call Now to Book a Consultation