Short answer: Standard white marbelite plaster is the most affordable concrete pool finish, but it is made with soft marble aggregate and is the quickest to etch, stain and roughen. PebbleQuartz® keeps the smooth, uniform look of plaster but uses harder silica-based aggregate, so it outlasts plaster and traditional quartz. PebbleTec® pebble finishes, such as PebbleTec® Original and PebbleSheen®, are the most durable of the three; the manufacturer says they often last for decades.
What is marbelite plaster?
Marbelite (also called marcite or white plaster) is the traditional pool finish: white cement mixed with crushed marble. It gives the classic bright, light-blue water and has the lowest upfront cost.
The trade-off is durability. Marble is a soft, calcium-based stone, and cement-based plaster is vulnerable to water chemistry. Over the years it tends to etch, stain, mottle and turn rough to the touch, which is why plaster pools are resurfaced more often than any other finish.

What is PebbleQuartz®?
PebbleQuartz® is made by Pebble Technology International, the company behind PebbleTec®. It gives the clean, smooth, uniform look of a plaster finish, but uses silica-based quartz aggregate instead of soft marble. The manufacturer describes it as delivering much greater durability than traditional marble-based quartz and plaster finishes.
It is a good fit for homeowners who love the classic smooth, bright look but want a finish that holds up longer than plaster.
What are PebbleTec® pebble finishes?
PebbleTec® finishes use small, natural pebbles bound in cement and exposed at the surface. Two of the most popular:
- PebbleTec® (the Original): the finish that started the category. The most natural texture and the deepest colour, with a riverbed look.
- PebbleSheen®: slightly smaller pebbles give a more refined, comfortable texture while keeping the natural pebble look.
The family also includes smoother and more polished options (such as PebbleFina®, PebbleBrilliance®, PebbleEssence® and PebbleBreeze®) for homeowners who want extra sparkle or a velvety feel. You can see the full range at pebbletec.com.

Marbelite vs PebbleQuartz vs PebbleTec: how do they compare?
| Marbelite plaster | PebbleQuartz® | PebbleTec® Original / PebbleSheen® | |
| Aggregate | Soft crushed marble | Hard silica-based quartz | Natural pebbles |
| Look | Smooth, bright white | Smooth, uniform | Natural pebble, rich colour |
| Feel underfoot | Smoothest when new; roughens with age | Smooth | Textured (Original) to refined (Sheen) |
| Stain and etch resistance | Lowest | Good, a step above plaster and quartz | Highest |
| Typical lifespan | Shortest | Longer than plaster or traditional quartz | Longest: often decades, per the manufacturer |
| Colour options | Mostly white | White | Wide range |
| Upfront cost | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
Every finish depends on quality application and balanced water chemistry. Check the manufacturer's current warranty for each product.
Is a pebble finish worth the extra cost?
Look at the cost per year rather than the price on day one. A finish that lasts far longer means fewer resurfacing jobs, and each resurfacing means draining the pool, a crew in the backyard and a lost part of the swim season. For many homeowners, especially in a climate as hard on pools as ours, a longer-lasting finish ends up being the better value. It is the same thinking behind where to save and where to invest in your pool.
What makes any pool finish last longer?
- Balanced water chemistry. Low pH or aggressive water slowly dissolves cement-based finishes; high calcium leaves scale. Regular testing protects the finish more than anything else.
- A proper start-up. The first weeks after application are critical to how the surface cures and wears.
- A certified applicator. PebbleTec® finishes are applied by trained, manufacturer-approved installers. Ask whether yours is.
- Winter care. In Ontario, the pool should be properly closed and the water level managed so the finish is not stressed over winter. See our winterizing guide.

What should I ask before choosing a finish?
- Is it marbelite, a quartz finish or a pebble finish, and which exact product?
- Is the applicator certified by the manufacturer?
- What warranty comes with it, and does it need to be registered?
- What is the start-up process for the first few weeks?
- Can I see the finish in a filled pool, not just a dry sample?
The finish is one of the things that separates a concrete pool from the other pool types. See how they compare in our concrete vs vinyl vs fiberglass guide, and what to look for in pool coping for Ontario.
Why GTA homeowners trust Gib-San
- Since 1973. Three generations of the Gibbs family, building pools in the GTA for 54 years.
- 9,000+ completed projects, so we have seen how every finish wears over time.
- Named one of the Top 50 Builders in North America by Pool & Spa News.
- Our own team from design to service, with 150+ in-house staff.
- We stay after the build. Our service department cares for Gib-San pools for decades.
Want to see these finishes in person?
Book a design consultation to compare samples side by side, or thinking of refreshing an older pool? See our signs you need a pool remodel.
PebbleTec®, PebbleQuartz®, PebbleSheen®, PebbleFina®, PebbleBrilliance®, PebbleEssence® and PebbleBreeze® are registered trademarks of Pebble Technology International. Product descriptions are from the manufacturer's published materials.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between PebbleTec and PebbleSheen?
Both are PebbleTec pebble finishes. PebbleTec Original uses standard-size pebbles for the most natural texture; PebbleSheen uses slightly smaller pebbles for a smoother, more refined feel.
Is PebbleQuartz the same as plaster?
It looks and feels like a smooth plaster finish, but it uses hard silica-based aggregate instead of soft marble, which makes it more durable than plaster or traditional quartz.
Why is my marbelite pool rough or stained?
Usually water chemistry over time: etching from low pH, or scale and staining from minerals and metals. It is often a sign the pool is due for resurfacing.
Can I upgrade a plaster pool to a pebble finish?
Usually, yes. During resurfacing, the old finish is prepared or removed and the new finish is applied over a sound base.
What is the best time to resurface a pool in Ontario?
Spring through early fall, when temperatures allow proper application and start-up. Booking early helps you get on the schedule before swim season.